New Haven's Best Pizza

The best local style pizza you'll find in New Haven. Come on in and enjoy our pizza or Order Online for pick up to enjoy at home or with friends.

Order Online View Menu
A pepperoni pizza is sitting on a table next to a basket of bread.
A white background with a few lines on it
  • A white background with a few lines on it

    "Always a pleasure to stop here when back in New Haven. The pizza is always in point and so is the service. I would recommend this place to anyone in search of good food."

    Real M.

    Button
  • A white background with a few lines on it

    "So another great pizza spot in New Haven! The crust is a little thicker than the typical New Haven brick-oven style that I love, but this is still a solid pizza with great flavor."

    Markus L.

    Button
  • A white background with a few lines on it

    "We were staying for a couple of nights in New Haven and we stumbled upon this restaurant. We saw the reviews and we knew we had to try it. Whalley Pizza gives a good amount of food for a great price! We recommend coming here if you're around!"

    Jessica M.

    Button
A white background with a few lines on it

OPEN for Dine-In

& Online Ordering

Monday - Saturday:

11am - 9pm